India now has the world's fifth-largest economy and one of its fastest-growing, expanding at roughly 7 percent a year, but for decades it was a byword for stalled development. A new book reviewed by Foreign Policy columnist Sumit Ganguly, Devesh Kapur and Arvind Subramanian's A Sixth of Humanity: Independent India's Development Odyssey, traces how the country got from one condition to the other, and argues the early choices that held it back still shape its problems today. Kapur, a political scientist, and Subramanian, an economist, spent 824 pages walking through the policy record since independence, and Ganguly calls the result a milestone in the scholarship on India's political economy.
The book's central revision, per the review, is that India is usually described as having embraced import-substitution industrialization, the tariff-heavy strategy proposed by economist Raúl Prebisch to protect "infant industries" in developing countries. Kapur and Subramanian argue India never actually implemented that strategy in a way that could have worked: it shut off foreign supply chains and built an unwieldy, loss-making public sector, but also choked off the private sector that might have made the approach pay off. The result, Ganguly writes, was that close to 60 percent of India's population remained in poverty between 1950 and 1980, undercutting the era's own defense that India's performance beat British colonial rule.
Ganguly highlights the book's account of how India's democratization actively undermined its fiscal discipline. As the Indian National Congress lost ground to more competitive politics in the late 1960s, Prime Minister Indira Gandhi turned to bank nationalization and expanded subsidies to shore up support, and the review notes that few politicians since have been willing to unwind those popular measures. Kapur and Subramanian trace a direct line from that shift to today's crony capitalism, as large firms consolidated the market Gandhi-era policy helped protect. The tax base never recovered either: agriculture was constitutionally exempted, loss-making state enterprises drained the treasury, the politically influential middle class secured exemptions, land transactions went untaxed even after post-1991 land values soared, and extortionate rates on the wealthy during India's socialist period drove widespread evasion.

